Mister Pizza


1065 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222

614 Grover Cleveland Hwy, Buffalo, NY 14226

About Mister Pizza

Mister Pizza Elmwood is a distinguished pizza establishment that has been serving the Buffalo, NY community for over 46 years, making it a true legend in the local pizza scene. Located at 1065 Elmwood Ave., Buffalo, NY 14222, this pizzeria prides itself on combining wholesome ingredients like fresh vegetables, meats, and cheeses with an authentic Italian recipe. This commitment to quality has helped Mister Pizza maintain a strong record of customer satisfaction through the years.

The menu at Mister Pizza Elmwood has evolved to meet the changing tastes of its customers. While it originally focused on a wide variety of specialty pizzas, the menu has expanded to include a large selection of chicken wings, salads, and subs. This expansion ensures that there’s something for everyone, whether you’re in the mood for a classic pizza, a hearty sub, or a fresh salad. All menu items are made with the highest quality ingredients, underscoring Mister Pizza’s dedication to delivering delicious and satisfying meals.

Customers have expressed particular fondness for several items on the menu, including the chicken wing pizza, which comes highly recommended. The sesame pizza crust is another unique offering that sets Mister Pizza apart from other pizzerias. Wing lovers will appreciate the 30 wing deal that pairs perfectly with any pizza, noting the wings’ crispy exterior and tasty interior. The terrific white pizza and the use of open pit BBQ sauce on wings and fingers are also highlighted as customer favorites.

For those with specific dietary preferences, Mister Pizza Elmwood offers excellent vegan options, including the best vegan pizza around, according to customer testimonials. The flexibility to order specialty pizzas by the slice through the Slice app, with the option to use vegan cheese, is particularly appreciated.

The service at Mister Pizza Elmwood is noted for being exceptionally quick, a crucial factor for those seeking a warm, delicious meal after a long day. The pizzeria’s convenient location on Elmwood Avenue, coupled with the availability of a parking lot, makes it an accessible choice for dine-in or take-out. Additionally, its late operating hours cater to late-night cravings, ensuring that delicious pizza is just a call away, even at 9-10pm.

In summary, Mister Pizza Elmwood stands out not only for its longstanding tradition and commitment to quality but also for its ability to innovate and cater to the diverse preferences of its customers. Whether you’re a fan of traditional pizzas or looking for vegan options, Mister Pizza Elmwood promises satisfaction with every order.

Buffalo Location

1065 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222

Amherst Location

614 Grover Cleveland Hwy, Buffalo, NY 14226