Sweet Jenny’s

• Website
• Facebook
• Instagram
• X

Location:

56 E Spring St, Buffalo, NY 14221
716-631-2424

About Sweet Jenny’s

Nestled in the heart of the historic 1811 Williamsville Mill, Sweet Jenny’s is more than just a place to indulge your sweet tooth; it’s a destination for handcrafted delights and heartfelt hospitality. Since 1985, this locally owned, family-run shop has been charming customers with its small-batch ice cream, artisan chocolates, and a warm, welcoming atmosphere.

Freshness You Can Taste

At Sweet Jenny’s, they take the word “fresh” seriously. Every scoop of ice cream and every piece of chocolate is crafted on-site, with the ice cream often served the very day it’s made. The team’s dedication to using only the finest ingredients ensures that each bite is bursting with flavor. The secret to their thick, rich ice cream? A unique micro-batch freezing method that eliminates excess air, keeping every spoonful dense and creamy. Their ice cream is always hand-packed, a loving touch that speaks to their commitment to quality.

For those craving variety, Sweet Jenny’s has something for everyone. The shop features 12 signature ice cream flavors daily, alongside hundreds of rotating specialties like vegan ice cream, sorbet, low-fat frozen yogurt, fat- and sugar-free options, and even dog-friendly ice cream for your four-legged friends. Whether you’re a classic chocolate lover or an adventurous flavor enthusiast, you’re sure to discover a new favorite.

Chocolates That Shine

The chocolates at Sweet Jenny’s are nothing short of extraordinary. Each piece is hand-dipped in their shop, using a proprietary blend of cacao that makes their creations one of a kind. Much like their ice cream, the chocolates are crafted in small batches to ensure the highest quality. From silky truffles to seasonal specialties, Sweet Jenny’s chocolates are a labor of love that’s perfect for gifting or savoring yourself.

Family Values in Every Detail

Sweet Jenny’s is the kind of place where the owners are more than just names on a sign. Howard and Tara Cadmus, along with their two young sons, can often be found serving behind the counter. This personal touch is at the heart of their business, making every visit feel like a warm reunion with old friends. Their passion for excellent customer service and dedication to their craft has made Sweet Jenny’s a beloved fixture in the Williamsville community.

A Comic Lover’s Paradise

The Sweet Jenny’s experience doesn’t end with sweet treats. Upstairs in the 1811 Mill, you’ll find 1811 Comics, a treasure trove for fans of comics and collectibles. Whether you’re hunting for the latest releases, exploring vintage finds, or snapping photos with life-sized superhero statues, there’s something to delight every comic enthusiast. The store even buys comics, toys, and collectibles, ensuring there’s always something new to discover on your next visit.

Stop By for a Sweet Escape

Sweet Jenny’s is more than just a shop; it’s a celebration of quality, fun, and family. From their artisan ice cream and chocolates to the nostalgic charm of 1811 Comics, every corner of this charming establishment invites you to slow down and indulge in life’s little pleasures. Whether you’re a local or just passing through Williamsville, a visit to Sweet Jenny’s is an experience you won’t soon forget. Stop by to share a smile, savor a scoop, and discover why Sweet Jenny’s has been a cherished family tradition for nearly 40 years.