About The Old Orchard Inn 

Old Orchard Inn: A Timeless Dining Experience in East Aurora

Nestled in the scenic beauty of East Aurora at 2095 Blakeley Corners Rd, the Old Orchard Inn stands as a testament to the charm and warmth of Western New York. This family-owned American restaurant has become a beloved landmark, offering both locals and visitors a slice of history, comfort, and exceptional dining. With roots tracing back to 1931, the Old Orchard Inn blends tradition with modern touches, making it an exceptional destination for all occasions.

A Rich History, A Family Legacy

The story of the Old Orchard Inn is one of family heritage and dedication. Owned and operated by the Romanello family since 1997, the restaurant is part of a larger legacy that includes several Western New York dining icons, such as the Roseland in Buffalo’s historic Italian neighborhood. Today, Melissa Romanello, the owner and general manager, continues to carry the torch, creating a welcoming space while honoring the Inn’s storied past.

Adding to its charm is the restaurant’s setting in a historic building with rustic, homey touches. It’s not just a place to eat; it’s a destination steeped in character and community spirit.

Farm-to-Table Freshness

One of the standout features of the Old Orchard Inn is its commitment to quality ingredients. Head Chef Abigail Prior oversees not just the kitchen but also the Inn’s 12-acre farm, where fresh produce is grown and used daily to enhance the menu. Every dish is made in-house, from scratch, and with care—this hands-on approach is evident in every bite.

Menu staples include family recipes like the prized Romanello-family manicotti and comforting classics such as the rich and savory pot pie. Vegetarian or meat-lover, you’re bound to find something satisfying here, all created with farm-harvested ingredients for unbeatable freshness.

A Menu That Feels Like Home

The Old Orchard Inn specializes in classic American dishes with a touch of gourmet flair. Their menu is a celebration of bold flavors and hearty portions, drawing diners back time and time again. Weekly specials add an extra layer of excitement, with highlights such as:

• Thursday Surf & Turf – A delectable pairing of 4 oz filet mignon and lobster tail, served with a demi-glace and drawn butter.
• Friday Twin Lobster Tails – Two perfectly broiled tails for seafood lovers, served with lemon and hot drawn butter.
• Saturday Prime Rib – A mouthwatering, slow-roasted cut of beef topped with a rich Jus Lie.
• Sunday Roast Turkey Dinner – A homestyle feast complete with stuffing, gravy, and a cranberry-orange relish.

Pair any of these entrées with their handcrafted sides or a featured wine selection, and you’re in for a meal that feels like a warm hug.

A Space for All Occasions

Whether you’re in search of a romantic dinner spot, a place to catch up with loved ones, or to celebrate a special event, the Old Orchard Inn caters to all. Its rustic and charming interior creates a cozy backdrop for any gathering. Meanwhile, their curbside pickup options offer the same exceptional flavors for those who want to enjoy them in the comfort of their own homes.

Planning a special event? The Old Orchard Inn offers private dining services, making it the perfect venue for hosting everything from intimate family gatherings to formal celebrations. The team’s commitment to hospitality ensures that every detail is managed flawlessly.

A Dining Destination You Can’t Miss

For a true taste of East Aurora’s rich culinary traditions, Old Orchard Inn is a must-visit. With its dedication to farm-fresh ingredients, thoughtful menu offerings, and warm, welcoming atmosphere, it’s more than just a restaurant—it’s an experience to savor.

Plan your visit today at 2095 Blakeley Corners Rd or call to make a reservation. Whether you dine in, pick up, or book a special event, the Old Orchard Inn will leave you with a lasting impression—and a satisfied appetite.

East Aurora Location

2095 Blakeley Corners Rd, East Aurora, NY 14052